Chapter 5 - THE NORTH GARDEN CAVEThe night air outside was biting, carrying the sharp, metallic tang of Lake Michigan as it rolled inland over the manicured lawns. The moon was hidden behind a thick blanket of gray clouds, leaving the estate illuminated only by the amber glow of the security lamps along the gravel paths.
I walked a half-step behind Luca, my hands jammed deep into the pockets of my wool coat. Neither of us spoke. Every step crunching against the gravel sounded unnaturally loud in the quiet night.
We passed the shimmering expanse of the swimming pool, skirted the edge of the glass greenhouse where the sweet smell of damp soil and tomato vines hung in the air, and headed toward the dense line of weeping willows at the far edge of the property.
Hidden behind the trees stood the carriage house.
It was a small, two-story brick building with ivy climbing up its weathered walls and heavy wooden double doors secured by a modern digital keypad lock—a lock that clearly didn't belong on a historic structure.
Luca walked up to the keypad. He didn't punch in a code.
Instead, he pulled a small metallic device from his pocket—a keycard programmer—and pressed it against the sensor.
Bip.
A tiny green light flashed.
Clack.
The heavy deadbolt slid back into the door with a sharp, mechanical sound.
Luca pulled the right door open. A rush of stale, damp air spilled out into the night, carrying the smell of old dust, fading lavender, and something sharp and chemical—like rubbing alcohol and old medicine.
"Stay here," Luca whispered, pulling a small black flashlight from his belt and clicking it on.
"I'm coming with you," I said firmly.
He looked like he wanted to argue, but one glance at my face told him I wasn't going to wait by the trees. He gave a sharp nod and stepped inside.
The beam of the flashlight cut through the darkness, illuminating a narrow wooden staircase leading up to the second floor, and a small, partitioned living space on the ground floor. There was a narrow iron cot with a rumpled floral quilt, a small wooden table with a half-empty pitcher of water, and a stack of dog-eared paperback books piled neatly in the corner.
On the table sat a child's crayon drawing—a picture of a little girl with curly hair standing next to a tall man with a smiling face, labeled DADDY & SOPHIE.
My hand flew to my mouth. Sophie hadn't drawn that yesterday. That drawing looked like it had been made three years ago, before Sophie's mother supposedly vanished.
"Isabella?" Luca called out, his voice echoing off the brick walls. "Isabella, it's me. It's Luca."
There was no answer from the ground floor.
Only a faint, scratching sound coming from above—from the second-floor loft.
Luca didn't wait. He bounded up the wooden stairs two at a time, his flashlight beam slicing back and forth across the upper landing. I followed closely behind, my boots thudding softly on the old wood.
At the top of the stairs was a heavy wooden door with a sliding iron latch on the outside.
The latch was thrown back. The door was cracked open an inch.
Luca pushed it wide.
The flashlight beam illuminated a small, windowless room under the slanted eaves of the roof. There was no bed here—only a mattress rolled out on the floor, a small ceramic bowl, and a woman sitting with her knees pulled up against her chest, her face hidden in the shadows.
She wore a faded gray sweater that was far too large for her thin frame. Her dark hair fell in tangled waves around her shoulders.
At the sound of the door opening, she flinched violently, raising a pale, skeletal hand to shield her eyes from the sudden glare of the flashlight.
"No," she whimpered, her voice a dry, raspy whisper that sounded like paper scraping against stone. "Please... don't give me the medicine. I didn't mean to talk to the little girl. I just saw her through the window... I just wanted to see my baby..."
Luca dropped the flashlight. It clattered against the floorboards, rolling to a stop against the baseboard, leaving the beam pointing upward, casting long, grotesque shadows across the ceiling.
He fell to his knees.
"Isabella," he choked out, his voice breaking entirely as he crawled across the floor toward her.
The woman froze. She slowly lowered her hand, blinking against the light, staring at the man kneeling in front of her.
"Luciano?" she whispered, as if testing a word she hadn't spoken in a thousand years.
"Oh, God," Luca sobbed, pulling her frail, trembling body into his arms. "Oh, God, Isabella, I'm so sorry... I'm so sorry..."
She didn't push him away. She collapsed against his chest, her thin arms wrapping around his neck with a desperate, crushing strength, while the tears finally broke free, wetting the collar of his black shirt.
And as I stood in the doorway of that dark, forgotten room, watching a man who owned half of Chicago break down into sobs of pure agony, I realized something terrifying:
May you like
The nightmare wasn't over.
Because down at the main house, half a mile away, the security system suddenly began to shriek with a high-pitched, piercing alarm—and the front gates were swinging wide open for an uninvited guest.
Related Stories
