Chapter 3 - THE PHOTOGRAPH BEHIND THE OIL PAINTINGThe nursery upstairs was warm and smelled faintly of lavender and baby powder, but the air felt thin, charged with an electric tension that even Sophie could sense.
I helped her change into her soft cotton pajamas, listening as the distant rumble of shouting drifted up through the floorboards from the ground floor.
"Hannah?" Sophie asked, clutching her stuffed rabbit to her chest. "Is Daddy going to be mad at me for telling him about Uncle Nick?"
"No, sweetheart," I said, sitting on the edge of her white canopy bed and smoothing her hair. "Your daddy is never mad at you for telling the truth. Grown-ups just have a lot of messy secrets, and sometimes it takes a while to clean them up."
"Like my cupcakes?"
"Exactly like your cupcakes," I smiled, though my throat felt tight.
She yawned, her heavy eyelids drooping. Within five minutes, the exhaustion of the long, terrible evening caught up with her, and her breathing slowed into the steady rhythm of sleep.
I pulled the quilt up to her chin, placed the little plastic dinosaur on her nightstand beside her mother's silver locket, and quietly slipped out into the hallway.
The mansion was enormous—a sprawling limestone estate overlooking the lake—and at night, it could feel like a labyrinth. I walked down the carpeted corridor toward the grand staircase, intending to check if Luca needed me to bring up water or handle anything for Sophie in the morning.
As I passed the library, the heavy oak door was propped open an inch.
A shaft of amber light spilled out across the dark hardwood floor.
"I told you, Luca, you're looking at it all wrong!"
It was Nicholas's voice.
I froze, stepping back into the shadow of a marble pillar. I thought Nicholas had left through the garage.
"Shut your mouth, Nick," Luca growled from inside the room. His voice carried a brutal, raw edge that made my skin prickle. "Marcus caught your car at the south gate before you could clear the property line. You're not going anywhere."
I peered through the crack in the door.
The massive oil painting of Luca's grandfather had been swung out on its brass hinges, revealing the dark, square cavity of the wall safe. The safe door hung wide open.
On the mahogany desk sat a thick, leather-bound wedding album, its pages flipped open to the very beginning.
Luca stood over the desk, his massive frame rigid. In his right hand, he held a framed photograph—the one taken twelve years ago on the yacht.
Nicholas sat in a leather armchair, a split lip leaking a thin line of blood onto his white collar. He looked up at his older brother, panting, trying to maintain a cocky grin that didn't quite reach his terrified eyes.
"You're making a big deal out of nothing, man," Nicholas laughed nervously, wiping his mouth with the back of his hand. "So Vanessa is Isabella's cousin. So what? Families have secrets."
"That's not a family secret, Nick," Luca said quietly, stepping closer to his brother. He pointed a finger at the woman standing beside him in the photograph. "That woman in the picture isn't Isabella's cousin. That's Vanessa. Look at the date stamped on the corner of the print. June 14, 2014. Two years before I ever met Isabella."
Nicholas stopped smiling.
"You introduced me to my wife," Luca continued, his voice dropping into that terrifying, flat whisper. "You brought her to my birthday party at the club. You told me she was an orphan from out of town who needed a fresh start. But she wasn't an orphan, was she? She was engaged to you first."
The silence in the library was absolute.
"She wasn't just engaged to me, Luca," Nicholas spat out, the bravado suddenly draining away, replaced by bitter resentment. "She was supposed to marry me. But I didn't have your title. I didn't have your stake in the shipping empire. Dad left everything to the golden boy, and Isabella figured it out just in time to trade up."
Luca didn't hit him. He just stared down at his younger brother as if he were looking at something crawling out from under a rotting log.
"And the baby?" Luca asked. "The one Vanessa claims is mine?"
Nicholas looked away, staring stubbornly at the Persian rug.
"It's not yours, Luca," Nicholas muttered. "It's mine."
My hand flew to my mouth to stop a gasp from escaping.
Luca closed his eyes for a long, agonizing second. When he opened them, the last shred of brotherly loyalty he possessed had burned away to ash.
"Get out," Luca said.
"What?"
"Get out of my house. Take your car, take your clothes, and don't ever let me catch you within city limits again. If you breathe near my daughter, I won't just throw you off the docks—I'll bury you where nobody will ever find the shovel."
Nicholas scrambled out of the chair, grabbing his jacket from the back of the sofa, and bolted past me in the hallway without even looking my way, his footsteps echoing wildly down the grand staircase.
I stepped back into the shadows, my heart hammering against my ribs.
I thought the worst was over. I thought the truth had finally been dragged into the light.
Then Luca reached into the open safe, pulled out a small, flat wooden box that I had never seen before, and flipped open the brass clasp.
He pulled out a single, folded sheet of lined hospital stationery.
He unfolded it, read the first two lines, and his face turned the color of bone.
May you like
He didn't yell. He didn't drop the paper. He just whispered a name into the empty room—a name that made my blood run cold.
"Isabella..."
Related Stories
