Chapter 3 - THE PHOTOGRAPH BEHIND THE MIRROR

“He’s coming back,” Rory whispered, her small hands frantically trying to push the heavy front door closed.
“Rory, wait!” I said, pressing my palm against the wood. “Open the door. I’m here to help you.”
“No, no, you don't understand!” she cried, tears spilling over her eyelashes. “If he finds you here, he’ll kill you! And he’ll blame me!”
“Rory, open the door right now,” I commanded, dropping my friendly bus driver persona and using the stern, immovable voice I used to use when my own five teenagers crossed the line.
The authority in my tone caught her off guard. Her hands froze on the doorframe.
She looked at me, trembling from head to toe, the fear in her eyes so profound it physically ached to look at.
Slowly, with a trembling hand, she unlatched the safety chain and pulled the door open.
“You shouldn't have come, Mr. Harmon,” she sobbed, stepping back into the dimly lit foyer. “You’re in danger.”
I stepped inside, pulling the door shut behind me and throwing the deadbolt. The house smelled faintly of lemon cleaner and old dust. It was eerily quiet, save for the ticking of a grandfather clock in the corner.
“Rory, what’s going on?” I asked, keeping my voice low and steady as I knelt down to be at eye level with her. “Whose footsteps did I hear? Who slammed that drawer?”
She looked away, wiping her nose with her sleeve. “Nobody. The house settled. That’s all.”
“Don't lie to me, sweetheart,” I said gently, reaching out to place a hand on her trembling shoulder. “I found the package under your seat on the bus. I know you’re terrified of something. And I know your stepfather isn't protecting you.”
Rory flinched at the mention of Arthur. Her eyes darted toward the hallway leading to the back bedrooms.
“The pills… you found them?” she whispered, her voice cracking.
“I did.”
“I didn't mean to lose them,” she cried, fresh tears breaking free. “I hid them inside my backpack, but it ripped. I didn't want them in my room. If he found them in my room…”
She couldn't finish the sentence. She didn't need to.
“Rory, whose pills are those?” I asked carefully. “Are they yours?”
She shook her head violently. “No! Gross, no! They’re… they’re my mom’s.”
“Your mother’s?” I frowned, my brow furrowing in confusion. “Why would your mother’s birth control pills be in your possession?”
Before Rory could answer, a loud, heavy thud echoed from the back of the house.
Thump.
We both froze.
“I thought you said he went to the job site,” I hissed, standing up quickly and pulling Rory behind me.
“He did!” she whispered frantically, her voice pitching in panic. “He always leaves until six! He never comes back early unless…”
Her eyes widened in absolute horror.
“Unless he forgot something,” she finished.
Heavy, deliberate footsteps began moving down the hallway toward the foyer.
Creak. Creak. Creak.
“Get in the coat closet,” I whispered, shoving Rory toward the narrow wooden door near the front entrance. “Quietly.”
She scrambled inside, pulling the louvered door shut just as the shadow of a broad-shouldered man fell across the hardwood floor of the entryway.
I didn't have time to hide.
I stood right in the middle of the hallway, squaring my shoulders as Arthur Vance stepped around the corner.
When he saw me standing in his house, the color drained from his face, instantly replaced by a dark, murderous fury.
“What the hell are you doing in my house?” Arthur snarled, his voice a low, gravelly growl.
He didn't look confused. He didn't look like a homeowner confronting an accidental intruder.
He looked like a man whose darkest secrets had just been interrupted.
“I think you know why I’m here, Mr. Vance,” I said, holding my ground, refusing to let the towering contractor intimidate me.
Arthur’s eyes narrowed into dangerous slits. He took two slow, menacing steps toward me, his heavy work boots hitting the floor like a hammer.
“You’re just a bus driver, old man,” Arthur hissed, balling his thick hands into iron fists. “You need to turn around, walk out that front door, and forget you ever laid eyes on this family. Or you won't live long enough to drive that yellow bus tomorrow morning.”
“Threatening an old man in his sixties won't make what’s happening in this house go away,” I fired back, my adrenaline surging. “I know about the girl. I know you’re terrorizing her.”
Arthur let out a harsh, barking laugh, but there was no humor in it. It was pure venom.
“Terrorizing her?” Arthur sneered, closing the distance between us until I could smell the stale coffee and sawdust on his breath. “I’m the only thing keeping that ungrateful little liar from destroying everything! You think you’re a hero, Harmon? You don't know a damn thing about what goes on behind closed doors.”
Before I could reply, a sudden, sharp noise came from behind me.
A muffled cough.
Coming from inside the coat closet.
Arthur’s head snapped past my shoulder. His eyes locked onto the louvered wooden door where Rory was hiding.
The temperature in the hallway plunged to zero.
“Is she in there?” Arthur whispered, his voice dangerously soft.
He lunged past me.
I threw out my arm, grabbing the front of his flannel shirt and jerking him backward. “Leave her alone!”
With a roar of pure rage, Arthur swung his right fist.
It caught me square in the jaw.
The impact sent a shockwave of pain through my skull, spinning me around and sending me crashing hard against the hallway wall. The world spun for a split second, a metallic taste of blood flooding my mouth.
Arthur didn't look at me. He ripped the closet door open.
Rory shrank back into the corner, sobbing hysterically, her arms raised over her face.
“Get out here, you little bitch!” Arthur roared, reaching his massive hand into the closet to drag her out by her hair.
“NO!” I screamed.
Adrenaline overpowering the pain in my jaw, I pushed myself off the wall, threw my entire sixty-two-year-old body into Arthur’s back, and tackled him hard to the floor.
We hit the hardwood with a thunderous crash, tumbling over each other in a frantic struggle.
“Rory! Run!” I yelled, gasping for air as Arthur tried to pin me. “Get out of the house! Call the police!”
Rory didn't hesitate. She scrambled out of the closet, scrambled past us, yanked the front door open, and bolted out onto the street, screaming at the top of her lungs.
Arthur shoved me off him with brutal strength, sending me crashing into a side table, shattering a ceramic lamp.
He scrambled to his feet, breathing heavily, glaring at the open front door where Rory had disappeared.
He knew he couldn't chase her down the street in broad daylight without drawing the attention of the entire neighborhood.
He turned his murderous glare back down at me, wiping a drop of blood from his lip.
“You just signed your death warrant, old man,” Arthur spat, pulling a heavy brass key from his pocket and walking toward the back hallway.
He disappeared down the corridor, and a moment later, I heard the loud, unmistakable screech of a locked deadbolt turning in a room at the end of the hall.
A room I hadn't noticed before.
A room without windows.
As I pushed myself up, wiping the blood from my chin, my eyes landed on a small wooden console table near the front door.
A framed family photograph had been knocked over during our struggle.
I picked it up.
It showed Arthur, Brenda, and Rory smiling on a sunny beach.
Except… as I looked closer at the glass, I noticed something strange.
The back of the frame wasn't sealed properly. A corner of white paper was sticking out from beneath the cardboard backing.
With shaking, bloodied fingers, I popped the cardboard tab open.
A folded piece of paper slid out into my palm.
I unfolded it.
It wasn't a photo. It was a handwritten legal document.
A certified copy of a birth certificate.
And when I read the names printed on the document under the heading Father and Mother, my breath caught in my throat, and the room seemed to tilt sideways.
Because Rory Carson wasn't Arthur Vance’s stepdaughter.
And Brenda Vance wasn't her mother.
According to the official state document dated fourteen years ago...
Rory Carson was Arthur Vance’s biological daughter.
May you like
And her mother was listed as a woman who had mysteriously vanished from Willow Glenn fifteen years ago.
A woman whose disappearance the local police had never been able to solve.