Chapter 3 - THE PHOTOGRAPH IN THE SKETCHBOOK
Nobody moved at the head of the dining table.
The crystal chandeliers above us hummed faintly in the silence, their warm light glinting off the faded surface of the photograph in Oliver’s small hand.
Lorenzo reached out slowly, as if touching the paper too quickly might turn it to ash. His broad fingers—the hands of a man who had built an empire out of concrete docks and iron discipline—trembled slightly as he took the photograph from the twelve-year-old boy.
I leaned in just enough to see over Oliver’s shoulder.
The picture had been taken in front of an old stone greenhouse overgrown with winter ivy. Helen Hayes looked thirty years younger, her dark hair pinned neatly beneath a wool cloche hat. Beside her stood Clara Bellini, Lorenzo’s late mother, wearing a camel hair coat and smiling down at the infant cradled in her arms. Embroidered on the corner of the baby’s blue wool blanket was the unmistakable intertwined B of the Bellini family.
Lorenzo turned the photograph over. Written in faded pencil across the back was a single date: November 14, 2004.
“That’s three days before the fire at the Lake Forest estate,” Lorenzo whispered, the color draining from his olive skin. He looked sharply at his younger brother. “Daniel, you were twelve years old that winter. You told our father that Mother went to the lake house alone.”
Daniel’s face was grey. For a second, the polished arrogance was completely gone, leaving behind a man who looked like he had just stepped onto thin ice.
“She did go alone,” Daniel stammered, his eyes fixed on the baby blanket in the photograph. “At least, that’s what Father told everyone after the roof collapsed. I swear to you, Lorenzo, I never saw that picture before tonight.”
Lorenzo didn't seem to hear him. He dropped to one knee beside Oliver so they were at eye level, completely ignoring the twenty wealthy strangers craning their necks down the length of the banquet table.
“Oliver,” Lorenzo said gently, though his voice vibrated with an intensity that made my skin prickle. “Did your grandmother give you the gold charm from the painting too?”
Oliver nodded. He set his worn green sketchbook on the edge of the table, reached beneath the collar of his borrowed navy jacket, and pulled out a thin silver chain.
Hanging right beside a simple silver cross was half of a heavy gold watch key, its jagged edge worn smooth by decades of rubbing against fabric.
Lorenzo reached into his waistcoat pocket and drew out his grandfather’s antique gold pocket watch. Dangling from the Albert chain was the other half of the key.
Without speaking, Lorenzo held his half against the charm around Oliver’s neck.
The jagged teeth of the broken gold fit together without a single gap.
Across the table, Margaret Sutton let out a soft gasp. Victoria took a step backward, her high heel catching on the hem of her red silk gown.
“Everybody out,” Lorenzo said, rising to his full height.
He didn't shout, yet twenty chairs scraped backward against the marble floor at the exact same instant. Waiters abandoned their silver trays. Within ninety seconds, the grand dining room was empty except for Lorenzo, Daniel, Victoria, Oliver, and me.
As soon as the heavy oak double doors clicked shut, Lorenzo turned on Victoria.
“You told me the watercolor was submitted anonymously to the foundation office,” Lorenzo said, his voice dangerously calm. “Who really brought Oliver’s painting into this house?”
Victoria’s lower lip quivered, all her haughty confidence evaporating now that the audience was gone. She looked at Daniel for help, but Daniel was still staring at the photograph in Lorenzo’s hand.
“I didn't know about the charm or your mother!” Victoria cried, her hands twisting together against her red silk skirt. “Three weeks ago, a man from Chicago namedJulian Vance approached Daniel at the riverboat club. He had photographs of Daniel’s private investment accounts in Cayman—the ones where Daniel lost two million dollars of the foundation’s endowment last autumn.”
Lorenzo’s head snapped toward his brother. “You gambled with the children’s endowment?”
“It wasn't gambling, it was a bridge loan that defaulted!” Daniel shot back, sweat beading along his hairline. “Vance works for Enzo Castellano. He told me Castellano would buy the debt quietly and hand back the ledger if I did two things. First, send him high-resolution photos of every painting created at the Eastside Children’s Center this winter. Second, make sure the portrait of the cafeteria worker was put up for auction tonight with a twenty-year commercial rights waiver signed by Helen Hayes.”
“Why the rights waiver?” I asked before I could stop myself.
Daniel looked at me with bitter resentment. “Because a standard charity sale doesn't require the subject of a portrait to provide a notarized proof-of-life residency form. The commercial waiver required Helen’s current street address and tax identification number. Vance didn't care about owning the painting. He used the auction paperwork to force me to track down where Helen Hayes was hiding—and then Victoria decided to slap her own name on the canvas to impress your society friends!”
“You told me the boy was an orphan who wouldn't care if we paid the shelter five hundred dollars!” Victoria hissed at Daniel.
“Wait,” Oliver interrupted, his brow furrowing as he looked up at Daniel. “You put my grandma’s address on that paper?”
Daniel hesitated, then looked away.
“Daniel,” Lorenzo said, taking two long strides until he was chest-to-chest with his brother. “Did you give Julian Vance the contract copy with Helen Hayes’s home address?”
“I emailed the scanned packet to Margaret’s courier at six o’clock tonight,” Daniel whispered.
My blood ran cold.
“Mr. Bellini,” I said, grabbing Lorenzo’s coat sleeve without thinking about my place as a maid. “Mrs. Hayes lives in the basement apartment behind St. Jude’s parish on Fourth Street. With her broken wrist, she goes to sleep at eight o’clock every night—and the latch on her back storm door has been broken since last Tuesday.”
Lorenzo checked his grandfather’s watch. It was eight-fifteen.
“Get your coat, Grace,” Lorenzo ordered, already reaching into his jacket for his car keys. “You’re coming with us. Oliver trusts you, and if Helen is there, she won't open the door for a stranger.”
He grabbed Daniel by the lapel of his charcoal suit. “You’re calling Castellano’s man right now and telling him there was a clerical error on the address. If a single hair on that woman’s head is touched before we reach Fourth Street, the Castellanos will be the least of your problems.”
We ran out through the side service entrance into the freezing November rain. Lorenzo bypassed his driver and unlocked a black sedan parked beside the courtyard fountain, ushering Oliver and me into the back seat before sliding behind the wheel himself.
As the heavy tires screeched out through the wrought-iron gates onto the slick pavement, Oliver sat rigid beside me, his small cold hand gripping mine so tightly his nails left crescents in my palm.
“Miss Grace,” Oliver whispered over the roar of the engine, his eyes wide with terror as streetlights flashed across his face. “Grandma told me something else yesterday when she gave me the picture.”
Lorenzo looked into the rearview mirror, his jaw tight as he cut across two lanes of downtown traffic. “What did she tell you, Oliver?”
Oliver swallowed hard, pulling his battered green sketchbook open to the very last page—a page he hadn't shown anyone at the dinner table.
May you like
Taped to the paper wasn't a drawing. It was an old, yellowed train ticket to Chicago dated the night of the Lake Forest fire, tucked inside a child’s medical bracelet from Mercy Hospital.
“She told me the baby in that photograph didn't die in the fire with your mother,” Oliver said, his voice trembling. “And she said I’m not her grandson.”
