Chapter 4 - THE LOCKED WARDROBE
Luca didn’t take the receipt from Sal’s hand. He stood on the narrow wooden porch between the woman he had planned to marry and the man who had been like a second father to him, looking as if the ground had vanished beneath his shoes.
“What is she talking about, Sal?” Luca’s voice was dangerously low. “When Elena disappeared five years ago, I tore this city apart for three weeks. You drove me to O’Hare Airport twice to check passenger manifests. You sat next to me in that bar on Taylor Street while I drank myself blind wondering how she could take my father’s check and leave.”
Sal didn’t pull his hand back. The yellowed clinic receipt fluttered slightly in the damp October breeze.
“I drove her across the state line to Milwaukee at two in the morning, Luca,” Sal admitted quietly. “In my own Buick, not the town car.”
The betrayal on Luca’s face was so stark I almost looked away. For a man in Luca’s position, surrounded by business partners and politicians who smiled while plotting behind his back, Sal had been the single piece of solid ground in his life.
“You watched me grieve her for five years,” Luca whispered. “You watched my father tell me on his deathbed that she was just a gold-digger who cashed his check, and you stood in the corner of that hospital room and didn’t say a single word.”
“Because your father wasn’t the one who wrote that check,” Sal said, his voice rising for the first time all night. “And if I had told you where Elena was that night, neither she nor that little boy inside would have lived to see the sun come up!”
“Stop listening to him!” Vanessa stepped between them, grabbing Luca’s lapel. “He’s lying to save himself! Your father paid Sal ten thousand dollars to get rid of Elena before she could ruin the merger between our families. When my father found out two years ago that Elena had left a bastard child with an old babysitter on West Addison, I started paying Mrs. Gable out of my own allowance to keep it quiet so it wouldn’t break your heart!”
I watched Vanessa carefully. Her hands were shaking, and she kept glancing down the street as if terrified another car might pull up to the curb. She wasn’t protecting Luca’s heart—she was terrified of someone else finding out we were here.
Before Luca could answer, the front door opened a crack.
“Mr. Russo?” Mrs. Gable peered out nervously. “Gio won’t get into bed until you read him the story like you promised. And it’s freezing out there. Come inside, all of you, before the neighbors start looking out their windows.”
Luca didn’t wait for an invitation. He brushed past Vanessa and Sal and stepped into the small, warm living room of the bungalow.
It was a humble, tidy house that smelled of cinnamon toast and pine cleaner. Plastic toy dump trucks were lined up neatly under a radiator, and a framed crayon drawing of a big black car with a smiling stick-figure driver in a cap hung on the wallpapered wall by the hallway.
Sitting in the middle of the worn braided rug was Gio, wearing thick yellow socks now and clutching a battered picture book about construction trucks. When he saw Luca walk in—tall, imposing, dressed in a bespoke black tuxedo—the five-year-old didn’t run away like he had from Vanessa on Tuesday night.
Instead, Gio tilted his head back and studied Luca with solemn, dark eyes.
“You’re the boy on the car,” Gio said simply.
Luca stopped dead in the middle of the rug. His throat constricted. “What did you say?”
Gio pointed a small finger toward the cardboard box in my arms, where the top of the silver picture frame was visible. “Uncle Sal’s picture. You’re the boy sitting on the big blue car with the grandpa.”
Luca dropped to one knee on the braided rug so he wasn’t towering over the child. His hands were trembling so badly he had to brace one against his knee. Up close, the resemblance between the two of them was staggering—the exact same widow’s peak, the same curve of the eyebrows, the same dark lashes.
“Yeah,” Luca managed to say, his voice cracking slightly. “Yeah, that’s me. My name is Luca.”
“I’m Gio,” the boy said, holding up his battered book. “Do you know about excavators?”
“A little bit,” Luca said, a raw, painful smile touching the corner of his mouth as tears gathered in his eyes. “My dad used to take me to watch them dig foundations when I was your age.”
“Uncle Sal takes me to the bridge on Thursdays to watch the barges,” Gio informed him proudly. Then he frowned, looking past Luca toward the front door where Sal and Vanessa had just stepped inside. “Why is the loud lady here?”
Vanessa stiffened by the coat rack.
“She’s leaving soon,” Luca said softly, never taking his eyes off his son. “Why don’t you go sit on the bed, Gio? Sal’s going to come read that book to you right now, and I’ll come say goodnight in a minute.”
Gio nodded, satisfied with that arrangement, and trotted down the short hallway toward the back bedroom with Mrs. Gable trailing behind him.
As soon as the bedroom door clicked shut, Luca stood up. He reached into Sal’s cardboard box in my hands and pulled out the silver-framed 1992 photograph. He flipped it over and pried off the gray velvet backing completely.
Inside the frame, pressed flat behind the photograph of eight-year-old Luca and his father, wasn’t just the Milwaukee clinic receipt. There was a folded piece of cream stationery and a small brass key tied to a faded blue ribbon.
Luca unfolded the stationery first. I stood close enough to see the neat, slanting handwriting across the page, though there were only three lines written on it:
Sal—If I don’t come back from the boat house tonight, don’t let them take Gio. The truth is inside the cedar wardrobe at my mother’s house. Tell Luca I never cashed the check. —Elena, Oct 14, 2023.
My breath caught. October 14, 2023. That was three years ago—almost to the day.
Luca stared at the note, his chest heaving. He looked up at Sal, then slowly turned his gaze toward Vanessa.
“Elena didn’t abandon him three years ago,” Luca whispered, the blood draining from his lips. “What happened at the boat house on October fourteenth?”
May you like
Vanessa backed up until her spine hit the front door. Her face was chalk-white. “I don’t know what that note is talking about! When I found out about Mrs. Gable two years ago, Elena was already gone!”
“That’s a lie,” Sal said quietly from the hallway entrance. He pointed at the delicate gold charm bracelet dangling from Vanessa’s right wrist—a bracelet with a tiny gold violin charm among the links that I had polished twice last month while cleaning her vanity upstairs. “Because that bracelet belonged to Elena Vance. And you started wearing it the morning of October fifteenth, three years ago.”
