Chapter 5 - THE UNION STATION TICKET
The silence in the study was so complete I could hear the grandfather clock ticking in the front hall.
Luca stared at the faded blue ticket in my palm, then lifted his eyes to my face. Slowly, instinctively, he stepped between me and his daughter.
“Why is your name written on a locker ticket from four days after my wife died?” Luca asked.
The warmth that had been in his eyes five minutes ago was gone, replaced by the cold, lethal calculation that made Luca Moretti the most feared man in Illinois.
“I don’t know!” I said, my voice rising in genuine shock. “Mr. Moretti, four years ago I wasn’t even living in Chicago! I was living in Joliet, working double shifts at St. Joseph’s Hospital in the laundry department!”
“Look at the handwriting,” Vanessa said sharply, stepping closer despite Luca’s warning glare. She pointed a manicured nail at the purple crayon letters. “That isn’t an adult’s writing. Look at the backwards E.”
Lily peeked out from behind Luca’s hip. She squinted at the little blue square in my hand.
“I used to make my Es like that when I was five,” Lily said quietly.
Luca looked down at her. “Baby, did you write this?”
Lily frowned, touching her own chin the way she always did when doing math homework at the kitchen island. “I don’t remember a blue ticket. Wait… is that purple crayon? Mommy only let me use purple crayons when we played the Post Office Game with the nice nurse.”
My knees nearly buckled.
The nice nurse.
Four years ago. St. Joseph’s Hospital in Joliet.
“Oh, my God,” I whispered, my hand flying to my mouth.
Luca’s hand closed around my wrist—not hard enough to hurt, but firm enough that I couldn’t take a step back. “Speak, Claire. Right now.”
“It wasn’t me,” I breathed, my mind racing back four winters. “It is my mother. Her name is Clara Dawson, mostly everyone at St. Joe’s called her Claire. That’s why she wanted me to apply for the housekeeping agency that services your neighborhood last year—she always asked me how the littleMoretti girl was doing, because she said she read about the bridge crash in the papers!”
“Your mother was a nurse at St. Joseph’s?” Arthur Bellini asked from the doorway, his face turning the color of old parchment.
“A trauma nurse in the burn and reconstructive unit,” I said, my pulse roaring in my ears. “Six months ago she had hip surgery, and her medical bills were piling up, so I took a second job here to pay her mortgage. Wait—four years ago, the night of the storm when the Mercedes went off the bridge, a woman was brought into St. Joe’s in Joliet by a long-haul trucker who found her walking along Route 53 in the rain.”
Luca’s grip on my wrist tightened until his knuckles turned white.
“Elena,” he whispered.
“I never saw her face!” I said quickly. “I only worked basement laundry! But I remember my mother coming home two days later crying because a mother and her little girl had been separated, and the woman was terrified her husband’s family would kill her if the hospital ran her fingerprints or insurance.”
“Why would Elena think I would kill her?” Luca’s voice cracked with a pain so raw it made even Vanessa flinch.
Marco emerged from the secret bookshelf passage, wiping soot from his sleeve. “Boss. Tunnel leads out to the old carriage house by the rear alley. Matteo had a car waiting. He’s gone, but he dropped his burner phone when he climbed the fence.”
Luca didn’t even look at the phone Marco held out. He couldn’t take his eyes off the gold watch and the blue Union Station ticket.
“Wait a second,” I said, the timeline suddenly crashing together in my head. “Lily… you were five years old when your mother died. Were you in the car on the bridge?”
“No,” Lily said, holding onto Luca’s belt loop. “Mommy left me at Grandma Rose’s house that night. Then two days later, a lady in a blue wool coat met me at the Lincoln Park Zoo carousel while my nanny was buying hot cocoa. She smelled like Mommy’s lavender soap, even though she had bandages on her cheek. She told me to write CLAIRE on the blue paper so the nurse lady would know it was from me, and then she put it inside the broken watch and told me to hide it under my dollhouse until I was nine.”
Tears sprang to my eyes as I looked down at the nine-year-old girl in her stocking feet.
For four years, Lily had kept a secret she didn’t even fully understand—remembering it only as a game with a bandaged lady at the carousel.
And Elena had survived the bridge crash.
She had gone to Joliet. My mother had treated her off the books. And four days after her supposed death, Elena had sneaked back into Chicago, met five-year-old Lily at the zoo, put the Union Station claim ticket inside her grandfather’s gutted pocket watch, and hidden it under the dollhouse.
“Why write your mother’s name on the ticket?” Luca asked me, his voice trembling.
“Because my mother commuted through Union Station every Friday to visit my aunt in Oak Park!” I said, realization dawning. “Elena must have tried to leave the locker ticket for my mother to pick up, couldn’t reach her before Matteo closed in, and gave it to Lily at the zoo instead!”
Luca looked at Arthur Bellini.
The old man was backing slowly down the hallway toward the front foyer.
“Arthur,” Luca said softly. “Marco, don’t let him reach the front door.”
Marco took two long strides and blocked Arthur’s path, his massive arms folded across his chest.
“You told me earlier that Elena caught you stealing three million from the family pension fund,” Luca said, walking slowly toward his lifelong advisor. “I know my wife. Elena wouldn’t have faked her death and abandoned her five-year-old daughter over three million dollars of my money. She would have walked into this study and told me to my face.”
Arthur swallowed hard, sweat glistening on his brow beneath the hall chandelier.
“Unless,” Luca continued, stopping six inches from Arthur’s face, “the person she caught stealing wasn’t just you. And the money wasn’t going into a bad stock trade.”
Vanessa looked from Luca to her father, genuine confusion written across her bruised face. “Dad? You swore to me Matteo was blackmailing you over the 2022 brokerage losses!”
“Shut up, Vanessa,” Arthur whispered miserably.
“Who was in the car with Elena on the Lake Shore Drive bridge, Arthur?” Luca asked, his voice dropping to that terrifying whisper. “Why didn’t the police find a body?”
“Because there was a body in the river!” Arthur blurted out, his shoulders caving inward. “Just not hers! And the police never dragged the south channel because Matteo paid the harbor patrol captain fifty grand to look the other way!”
I gasped.
“Whose body went into the water, Arthur?” Luca demanded.
Before Arthur could answer, the cellular phone in my apron pocket began to vibrate.
It was my personal cell phone. And there was only one ringtone set to the melody of Clair de Lune.
My mother’s nursing home recovery clinic.
I pulled the phone out with shaking hands and answered it on speaker. “Mom?”
“Claire, honey, thank God you picked up,” my mother’s breathless voice came through the tiny speaker. “You need to get out of that house right now. A man smelling like peppermint cigars just walked into my room here in Joliet asking for the nurse who treated the woman from the bridge in 2022.”
My blood turned to ice.
Matteo hadn’t fled Chicago. He was forty minutes down I-55 at my mother’s clinic.
Wait—why wasn’t my mother screaming?
May you like
“Mom,” I choked out, “where are you right now?”
“I’m in the clinic parking lot,” my mother said urgently. “Because the woman who shares my semi-private room recognized his voice from the hallway and pulled the fire alarm so we could get to my car. Claire… she’s sitting right beside me. And she wants to talk to Lily.”
