Chapter 2 - THE BLUE SNEAKER
The sound of the tea tray hitting the floor shattered the terrible silence in the living room. Porcelain cups shattered against the hardwood, sending dark liquid seeping into Meredith’s pristine white rug.
Meredith didn't even look down. Her eyes were fixed on me, wide and utterly drained of color.
"It's the pipes," she stammered, her voice pitching up an octave. "I told you, Caleb. The contractor did a terrible job with the HVAC ductwork. It makes knocking sounds."
I didn't answer her. I looked back down at the floor, where Lily was still kneeling.
"Daddy," Lily whispered, her lower lip quivering. "He's cold."
I dropped to my knees beside my daughter and pressed my ear directly against the polished oak. My heart hammered against my ribs like a trapped bird. I held my breath, straining to hear past the rush of my own blood.
Tap. Tap.
It wasn't a pipe. It was deliberate. It was human.
"Noah?" I shouted, slamming the flat of my hand against the floorboards. "Noah, are you down there? It's Daddy!"
"Stop it!" Meredith lunged forward, grabbing my shoulder with surprising strength. "You're scaring Lily! You're having an episode, Caleb. You need to calm down."
I shoved her hand away and stood up. The grief and exhaustion of the last fourteen months suddenly crystalized into a sharp, blinding clarity.
"What is under this room, Meredith?" I demanded, stepping toward her.
"A crawlspace!" she cried, backing away. "Just a sealed dirt crawlspace. There's no basement, Caleb, you know that!"
She was right. The house sat on a concrete slab, except for the slight elevation of this rear addition. But if there was no basement, there was only one place the sound could be coming from.
The heavy, ornate brass floor vent in the corner of the room.
I rushed over to it. The grate was screwed into the wood, designed to pull return air from the rest of the house. I hooked my fingers through the thick brass slats and pulled. It didn't budge.
"Caleb, stop!" Meredith shrieked, pulling her phone from her pocket. "I'm calling Caroline. You're completely losing your mind."
"Call her," I snapped, looking frantically around the room for a tool. I grabbed the heavy iron fire poker from the hearth.
"No!" Meredith dropped her phone and ran at me, but I was already wedging the forged iron tip under the edge of the brass grate.
With a sickening crunch of splintering oak, the screws gave way. The heavy grate flipped over.
A rush of stale, cold air hit my face. The duct was massive, lined with sheet metal, dropping down and curving sharply toward the sealed off, unfinished wing of the house that Meredith claimed she couldn't afford to complete.
I shined my phone's flashlight down into the dark expanse of the vent.
I didn't see my son.
But sitting perfectly upright in the dust, just out of arm's reach, was a child's object.
I recognized the faded blue canvas, the scuffed white rubber toe, and the knot I had tied myself.
It was Noah's other sneaker. The match to the one the police had found by the garden shed fourteen months ago.
My breath caught in my throat. I looked up at Meredith. She was backed against the far wall, her hands covering her mouth, shaking uncontrollably.
"He's been here," I whispered, the horror washing over me like ice water. "You knew."
May you like
Before Meredith could speak, a heavy, metallic CLANG echoed from the hallway behind her. It sounded like a heavy deadbolt sliding into place.
Someone was locking us inside the living room.
