Chapter 4 - THE BOATHOUSE IN LAKE FOREST
The rain hammered the windshield of my Buick as I pushed the speedometer past eighty on the Edens Expressway.
Ruth sat braced against the dashboard, clutching the black payroll ledger to her chest, while Celeste sat hunched in the back seat, her soaked red silk dress rustling every time we hit a slick patch of asphalt.
“Call the Lake Forest police,” I told Ruth, my knuckles white on the steering wheel.
“And tell them what?” Celeste interrupted sharply from the back. “That Grant Henderson is driving toward a business partner’s house? He hasn't committed a violent crime on paper yet, Maggie. If sirens show up while Grant is in that boathouse, he’ll claim Julian attacked him over the failed merger—and with Julian’s signatures on those forged bank documents, the police will arrest your son on the spot!”
She was right. Grant had spent thirty years cultivating police chiefs, judges, and aldermen over complimentary prime rib and vintage Bordeaux.
“How do we reach Julian directly?” I asked. “Give me his cell number.”
“I tried calling him twice before I ran to your car,” Celeste said, holding up her phone. “The signal out by the Lake Forest bluffs is dead in this storm. Wait—look at his notebook in the folder. There’s a landline number written under the boathouse address.”
Ruth flipped open the leather folder under the glow of the map light and dialed the ten digits on my phone.
It rang four times. Then five.
Finally, the line clicked open. There was no adult voice—only the faint sound of thunder rattling windowpanes and a small, hesitant breath.
“Hello?” a tiny voice whispered.
My heart stopped.
“Hello, sweetheart,” I said, forcing my voice to become as warm and steady as the mornings I used to read stories to my nieces. “Is this Lily?”
“Yes,” the little girl said. “Who is this? Mommy says I’m not supposed to answer the phone, but Mommy is in heaven and Daddy went downstairs to the dock because the gate alarm beeped.”
A five-year-old girl. Alone in the house while her father walked out into the dark toward Grant.
“Lily, my name is Maggie,” I said gently, blinking back hot tears. “I’m a good friend of your daddy’s, and I’m driving to see you right now. Are you inside the main house?”
“No, the big house is closed for winter,” Lily said, her voice small but brave. “We’re in the caretaker cottage above the boats. Daddy made me hot cocoa because my cough came back. Mr. Grant came to the door a minute ago.”
Ruth grabbed my forearm.
“Lily, listen to me very carefully,” I said, pressing the gas pedal harder as we took the exit ramp toward Sheridan Road. “Did Mr. Grant seem angry?”
“No, he brought me my stuffed rabbit I left at the hotel,” Lily said simply. “He told Daddy he wanted to help fix the mistake with Grandpa Arthur’s papers. They went down to the big safe in the boat room.”
Wait. Grant hadn't gone there to attack Julian.
He had used a five-year-old’s forgotten toy to get past Julian’s guard—so Julian would voluntarily open Arthur Vance’s biometric or combination safe for him.
“Sweetheart, I want you to play a hiding game with me,” I said calmly. “Does the cottage have a pantry or a closet where you keep extra blankets?”
“There’s the linen cubby under the window seat,” she said. “It has a little latch inside.”
“Take the phone and your bunny, climb into the window seat, and close the latch until you hear me call out the secret password. Do you know what the password is?”
“What?”
“Blue coat ducks. Just like the drawing your daddy made when he was a little boy.”
“Okay,” Lily whispered. “Daddy keeps that picture in his work bag because he says the nice lady at the park used to bring him butterscotch.”
A sob caught in my throat. Evelyn always carried butterscotch hard candies in the pockets of her blue wool coat.
We heard the soft rustle of blankets through the receiver, followed by the click of a wooden latch.
Three minutes later, I killed the Buick’s headlights as we turned down the long, winding gravel driveway flanked by towering stone pillars. At the bottom of the wooded bluff sat a two-story cedar boathouse jutting out over the churning black water of Lake Michigan.
Grant’s silver Mercedes SUV was parked at the base of the wooden exterior stairs, its engine still ticking in the cold rain.
“Celeste, stay in the car and lock the doors,” I ordered, reaching under my seat for the heavy iron tire wrench I kept for winter flats. “Ruth, stay at the top of the stairs by the cottage door. Do not let anyone go near Lily.”
“Maggie, you’re fifty-four years old,” Ruth hissed, grabbing my trench coat. “Grant has fifty pounds on you.”
“Grant has been stealing my life for thirty years,” I whispered. “He’s not taking tonight.”
I crept down the wet cedar steps toward the lower boat slip. Through the salt-stained glass panes of the workshop door, I saw the amber glow of a desk lamp.
Julian stood with his back to the open mahogany floor safe, holding a thick brass-bound ledger that looked startlingly similar to ours. His dark wool overcoat was soaked, his shoulders tense as he stared down at a yellowing sheaf of legal parchment.
Grant stood three feet away by the workbench, his tuxedo jacket off, his white dress shirt clinging to his broad shoulders.
“You see now, Julian?” Grant’s voice was smooth, heavy with counterfeit sorrow—the exact tone he had used when he convinced me to sign over my grandmother’s pearls in 2008. “Arthur Vance forced my hand. Maggie was bleeding out on the operating table at St. Jude’s. The hospital was going to let her die because we didn't have insurance! Arthur offered to pay the chief surgeon and clear our debts, but only if we gave him the baby his wife was desperate for. I told Maggie you died to save her from losing her mind with guilt!”
I froze outside the door, my hand on the cold brass knob.
What?
Inside the boathouse, Julian’s voice cracked with raw agony. “She nearly died giving birth to me? And you let her believe I was dead for thirty years to protect her?”
Julian’s shoulders slumped. He lowered the parchment toward the open fireplace grate where Grant had already lit a small pile of kindling.
Grant’s lie was brilliant. It was monstrous. And Julian—who didn't know my husband’s soul the way I did—was about to help him burn the only evidence of the adoption.
May you like
I kicked the workshop door open so hard the glass panes shattered against the brick wall.
“Don't you dare drop those papers in the fire!” I shouted, stepping into the light with the iron wrench in one hand and Evelyn’s cigar box under my arm. “My hospital bill in 1996 was covered by the diner’s union plan, Julian! And your father didn't pay the surgeon—he bought a restaurant!”
