Chapter 5 - Collateral Damage
While David’s world was burning, mine was finally healing.
I remained in the luxury private suite of the hospital for two weeks under the watchful eye of state troopers. My father rarely left my side. He sat in the corner armchair, reading legal briefs on his tablet, looking up every few minutes just to make sure I was still breathing.
During that time, I filed for an emergency absolute divorce, sole custody of my unborn child, and a lifetime order of protection against David and Sylvia Vance.
David, desperate and backed into a corner, hired the only sleazy defense attorney in town who was stupid enough to take his case. He demanded a preliminary hearing, claiming the protective order was based on fabricated evidence and that I was emotionally unstable.
He wanted to intimidate me. He wanted to drag me into a courtroom and use his aggressive lawyer tactics to break me on the stand, just like he had broken me in our kitchen for three years.
He completely forgot who I was.
I wasn't just the Chief Justice's daughter. I had graduated at the top of my class from Harvard Law. I had passed the bar exam with a near-perfect score. I had willingly given up my career, hiding my brilliance behind aprons and home-cooked meals, because David had told me a "good wife" supports her husband's ambitions first.
I was done hiding.
On the day of the hearing, I walked into the county courthouse. I wasn't wearing a scratching maternity dress or practical flats. I wore a tailored black maternity suit, my hair pulled back into a sharp, professional knot. I walked with my spine straight, flanked by my father’s elite private security detail.
David was sitting at the defense table. He looked terrible. The stress of unemployment and impending bankruptcy had aged him five years in two weeks. He looked up when I entered, expecting to see the timid, obedient wife he had trained me to be.
Instead, he saw a mirror image of the Chief Justice.
When the local judge—a man who was visibly sweating because Arthur Sterling was sitting in the gallery—called the court to order, David’s attorney stood up to present his motion.
“Your Honor,” the attorney sneered, adjusting his cheap tie. “This entire protective order is a farce. My client is a respected member of the bar. His wife, the plaintiff, is simply suffering from severe hormonal imbalance and is using her father’s political influence to punish a good man over a minor marital spat.”
The judge looked at me. “Does the plaintiff have legal counsel present?”
I stood up. I didn't tremble. I didn't look at the floor. I looked directly into David’s eyes.
“I am representing myself, Your Honor,” I said, my voice ringing clear and authoritative across the courtroom.
David’s jaw clenched. He leaned over to his attorney and whispered frantically.
“Your Honor,” I continued, ignoring them. “Opposing counsel claims this is a 'minor marital spat'. I have submitted into evidence Exhibit A: the medical records detailing severe bruising on my clavicle, consistent with being forcibly shoved into a granite counter by Sylvia Vance. I have submitted Exhibit B: the 911 dispatch audio log, which confirms David Vance refused to call for medical assistance for over fourteen minutes while I was suffering from a placental abruption.”
I paused, letting the silence hang in the air.
“And finally, Your Honor, I submit Exhibit C. An audio recording downloaded from the smart-home hub in our kitchen, which captured the entire incident.”
David’s face drained of blood. He shot out of his chair. “Objection! That’s a violation of wiretapping laws! I didn't consent to being recorded!”
I didn't even look at the judge. I looked right at David and smiled.
“The smart-home hub was registered in my name, purchased with my separate funds, and operates on an open-room microphone setting which you manually configured. Under state law, there is no reasonable expectation of privacy in a shared living space where an open-network device is explicitly visible. Shall I cite the specific case law, Mr. Vance, or do you want to retract your frivolous objection?”
The courtroom was dead silent. David stared at me, his mouth opening and closing. The woman he thought was a simple, submissive orphan had just legally eviscerated him in front of a judge.
May you like
“Objection overruled,” the judge stammered, wiping sweat from his forehead. “Play the recording.”
---
